Originally uploaded to Pastebin: December 24th, 2012
---

AUTHOR'S NOTE
--------------
This story was written a while back, at the start of December, but I never saved it. As a result, it's technically the first Flutterape Christmas story I wrote.
Special thanks to a wonderful Anon who went through the trouble of searching an old archived thread to find it. I love you dearly.

<3
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

>Night 120 in Equestria
>Sat up in bed reading a book by lamplight
>Feel a sudden chill
>Shiver and pull the covers up further
>Damn this is a good book
>Feel a shiver again
>Notice that the window is open
>Odd, you don't remember it being like that
>Get out of bed and shut it
>Back to bed
>Hear a faint moaning
>The hairs on the back of your neck stand up
>Feel a shiver once more, much colder than previous times
>See a faint blue/white glow from your left side
>Teeth chattering, look over at it
>A ghostly version of Fluttershy is hovering next to you
>Oh. Your. God.
Flutter...shy?
>"OooooOOOooooo! I am the ghost of Fluttershy! Tonight you will be visited by 3 spirits! Each will show you a vision of things that once were, things that are, and things that shall be!... If... umm... That's ok with you..."
Hang on, is this because Christmas is getting nearer?
>"What-mas?"
Chris- forget it.
>"OOOOOOOOOOOoooOOOO! BEWAAAARE!!! BEWAARRRREEE!!!"
Get the fuck out of my house
>"ok"
>She floats through the wall next to your bed
>Fucking Ghostshy
>Final chapter of your book
>Fucking hell this is exciting
>The detective just confronted the murderer, but things have taken a violent turn
>Thank god there's nothing here to distract you
>Look over to your shoulder
>Fluttershy looks back at you
>Look back to your book
>Freeze
AAAAAAAHH!
>"AAAAAAAAHHH!"
AAAAAAAAHH!!
>"AAAAAAAAAAAAHHH"
>"Oh, Anon. You startled me..."
I startled YOU?!
>"Yes... Is that your fetish?"
FUCKIN-
>"ok ok. Look. Umm. I'm the ghost of Rapemas past, here to show you events long past"
Rapemas. Are you fucking kidding me. I haven't even been here a whole year yet.
>"I know. But i'm here to show you a previous Rapemas"
You're a moron.
>"ok..."
>Suddenly you're not in your bed anymore
>You're stood on a bridge completely naked surrounded by snow
>Flutterghost is hovering next to you
>Even as a ghost you can tell when she's blushing
>However the hell that's even possible
>"Oh... my~"
Eyes up here, asshole. Why are we here?
>She points infront of you
>Fluttershy, the real one, is stood infront of you
>She's talking to... A stallion?
Who's that?
>"Me"
The other one, genius.
>"That's... umm..."
>"maolboyfren..."
What?
>"My old boyfriend"
The fact that you even had a thing for stallions amazes me
>No answer
>Fluttershy is looking longingly at the stallion
Hey, Flutters, Are you ok?
>She sniffs and wipes her eye with a hoof
>"I-I'm fine, really. Now watch"
>The real-past Fluttershy speaks up
>"Oh, Sunbeam. I'm so happy being with you! I-I think we should take it to the next level of our relationship!"
>Sunbeam smiles at her
>"I like you too, Fluttershy"
>This give Fluttershy pause
>"L-like or love?"
>Sunbeam looks nervous
>Ahh, you've seen this kind of thing before
>"W-well, I do like you a lot, Fluttershy, but umm..."
>"Do you love me?"
>"I..."
>"DO YOU LOVE ME OR NOT?"
>Fluttershy is fuming, her muscles tense and her entire body leaning into Sunbeam's face, using the Stare at full force
>"L-look. I really enjoy being with you, but i'm just not ready for that kind of thing. I can't say I love you yet, ok?"
>Fluttershy calms down
>"Ok. I understand"
>Sunbeam relaxes
>"Good..."
>Fluttershy's face takes on a much more sinister look
>"I'll just have to make you love me."
>"W-what?"
Oh god please say you didn't.
>Look at Fluttershy
>She smiles weakly
>"I... May have done..."
>Your eyes widen
>You quickly look back at Sunbeam and Realshy
>Fluttershy lunges on top of Sunbeam
>"You're going to love me, darling. Trust me"
>"Fluttershy what are you-"
>She kisses him deeply, he seems to relax a little bit and gets into the kiss
>Fluttershy starts rubbing between his legs
>That makes him tense up again
>"Fluttershy i'm really not ready for that-"
>She slaps him and starts Staring again
>"Quiet. You WILL love me."
>He starts whimpering
>Fluttershy always was stronger than she seemed
>She pins him down and places her crotch over his face while she starts licking the end of his member
>As expected, it goes hard.
>The curse of being male
This is... Horrible, Fluttershy.
>Realshy starts kissing and nibbling the end of Sunbeam's dick
>He moans slightly but cuts it off at the end to struggle some more
>She kicks him in the face
Ouch
>Ghostshy giggles
>"He only ever dated me because he was scared of me"
And you're proud of that, are you?
>"N-no... Not really..."
You're a terrible pony.
>"..."
>Real shy is now deepthroating Sunbeam while his head rolls around, his eyes unfocused and his nose bleeding profusely
>Suddenly he tenses up and starts cumming
>Fluttershy swallows every last drop
>She gets off him
>"There, that wasn't so bad, was it?"
>He starts crying
>You feel anger well up inside you
>The world starts going blurry
>Everything stretches before you and you feel yourself falling
>You blink
>Back in your bed
>Ghostshy next to you
>Waste no time in berating her
That was fucking horrible, even by your standards. That was low, Fluttershy. What ever happened to the poor guy?
>"He moved out of town the next day"
Fucking hell.
>Silence between you both
>"A-anyway..."
>"OoooOOooooOOOO!! Tonight you will be visited by two more spirits! One will show you what is, and the other shall show you what will be!"
Why.
>"Shush"
>She flies out the house through the wall
>Fuckin A
>Go back to your book
>2 hours later
>Trying to sleep after finishing it, but can't get the mental image of Fluttershy raping that poor stallion out of your mind
>Shiver slightly
>Uh oh
>Shiver again
>She wasn't lying
>Hear distant laughing as Ghostshy crashlands through your roof
>She's dressed in a festive outfit and laughing merrily
>"Haha! Hello there, Anon! I am the ghost of Rapesmas Present! I'm here to show you what will happen should you accept Fluttershy's love!"
Wait, you aren't Fluttershy? I thought you'd died and no one had told me.
>"Oh Anon! You're a crack up! Hahaha! Come! Let us make haste! Awaaaay!"
CAN'T I JUST GET SOME FUCKING SLEE-
>Out of your bed again
>Fucks sake
>Look around
>It's Ponyville during some kind of winter celebration
>Fillies are running around laughing and carollers are at doors singing happily
>The whole thing fills you with contentment and you feel relaxed and happier just looking at it
>Feel yourself smile
>Ghostshy is floating around basking in it all
>"Wonderful, is it not? This is Ponyville during Hearth's Warming Eve. A time of happiness and warmth so that ponies everywhere may shut out the cold that resides outside!"
>You've never seen Fluttershy this happy, she seems like Pinkie Pie. High on life.
So it's like Christmas then
>"Whatmas?"
Whatever.
>"...Come! Follow me to my cottage!"
>Float through the air alongside her towards Fluttershy's cottage
>Land outside a window
>Fluttershy beams at you and motions for you to look inside
>You do so
>And gasp
>You and Fluttershy are wrapped up in blankets drinking hot chocolate
>She's nuzzled up to you chest and you have your chin resting on the top of her head, your eyes closed and a massive smile on your face
>You both seem completely and utterly at peace with everything, hell even the bags under your eyes are gone
>You worked on those for 10 years as well
>Fucking Happiness
What... IS this?
>"This is life for you should you ever accept my love. All I want is for you to be happy, Anon. We could live out the rest of our days together like this. In each other's arms and loving company"
You don't have arms. You're a horse.
>"Whatever."
So this is life, huh? Seems pretty good. What's the catch?
>"No catch. You live out the rest of your days with me"
Ah. That's the catch.
Well sorry, Flutts. But that's not going to happen anytime soon. I don't do horses. Take me back.
>Her face suddenly changes
>It's no longer the jolly face of pure bliss you'd grown to like
>It's replaced with a look of fear, sadness and pity.
>"I'm sorry you feel that way, Anon. I really am."
>You blink and suddenly you're back in your bed
>Fluttershy is next to you, looking at you with eyes full of concern
>She gulps before speaking
>"T-tonight..."
>Uh oh.
>"Tonight you will be visited by one more spirit... It will show you what will come to pass."
>"I'm so sorry."
>And she's gone.
>That was unnerving, you have to admit.
>You've seen Fluttershy portray a lot of emotions, but never have you seen her so genuinely concerned about you
>You try to go back to sleep, but just end up lying in bed looking at the ceiling
>A third spirit? 
>What will come to pass?
>You think back to what you just saw
>You looked so happy with Fluttershy, you looked like a huge burden had been lifted from your shoulders
>And that hot chocolate looked and smelled amazing
>Fucking Bribery at work, here.
>You close your eyes and try to get the image of you nuzzling Fluttershy out of your head
>It's not working
>About an hour passes in complete silence
>You feel yourself drifting off to bed when you sense that something is horribly wrong
>An wave of dread washes over you and you feel incredibly cold, worse than any of the shivers you'd felt this night
>A faint thud is heard below your room
>Tense up and sit perfectly still
>Listen intently as heavy footfalls are heard coming up your stairs
>Slow and deliberate, each one echoing throughout the house
>Your door creaks open and your try not to cry out
>Fluttershy is stood in your doorway
>She's dressed in a shredded black cloak, and looks like she hasn't eaten or slept in years. 
>Her bony visage and sunken eyes behold you
>Ohshitohshitohshit
F...Fluttershy?
>The "thing" representing Fluttershy slowly trudges towards the foot of your bed
>It hold your gaze for what seems like forever
>Starting to get lost in the black holes that are her eyes
>She says nothing
>Merely points at you and all goes black
>You open your eyes and once again, you're not in your bed.
>And you're also naked
>For fucks sake.
>Flutterdeath turns towards you and looks at you for a few seconds
>Then she turns and walks away
>You look around
>Everything is silent, the snow of the ground is dark with the lack of light, and not even the moon is out.
>A low fog is all around you and you can barely make out the shape of Flutterdeath infront of you
>You decide to follow her, since she's your only way out of this mess
>Run to her side
>She doesn't acknowledge you, she just keeps walking
>Decide to make small talk with the being of your nightmares
Soo... What are you here to show me?
>You already knew. But you felt it was polite to ask
>No reply
>She just keeps walking
>You follow suit and eventually come to a dark house
>No lights in the windows
>Even in your spectral form you can feel the wind, it chills you to where your bones would normally be
>Peer inside a window
>The entire place is trashed
>Flutterdeath walks up to the door and straight through it
>You follow, walking through the solid wood
>Man that felt weird
>Wood molecules look funny
>You follow her into the living room
>Hang on, how did you know where it was?
>Look around
>Holy shit this is your house
Woah, why is my house so messed up? What happens in the future?
>No reply
ANSWER ME
>No reply
>She just looks at you with those damned eyes
>You feel pressured to do something
>You start walking around, looking for clues
>See a picture on the floor with a cracked frame
>Look at it closely
>It's your photo with the rest of the mane 6, it's your most treasured possession in this world
>The mane 6 have been scratched out though, and the only ones left are Fluttershy and you.
>You can see where this is going
>Walk into the kitchen and look for something to give you more clues
>Nothing
>Go back to Flutterdeath
Any ideas?
>She looks at the stairs
>Follow her gaze
>Slowly walk up them
>Even if you are spectral, and therefore it's safe to assume you're invincible, it scares you.
>Reach the landing and look towards your bedroom
>The door is shattered open
>Like a rabid animal broke it open
>See scratch marks all over the front of it
>Walk in and freeze
>There you are
>Naked, bloody and lifeless 
>Your dick is covered in blood and dried cum
>Your face is streaked with tears and reflects your final moments
>Fear, disgust and sorrow.
>Look towards where DeadAnon is looking
>The normally empty wall facing your bed now bares a message written in blood
>"YoU'Re GoInG To LOVE Me"
>Fear. 
>You feel nothing but fear.
>Fluttershy kills you
>She actually fucking kills you
>Start to panic
>It can't end like this
>Run downstairs to find Flutterdeath waiting patiently
This is a joke, right? I can't die! I can't! WHEN DOES THIS HAPPEN?
>She looks at the wall
>A calender is there on a slant
>You run over it it
>December 25th - 3002 After Discord (AD)
>That's this year.
>She kills you on this shitty little pony holiday because you keep rejecting her
>Sink to your knees, looking at the calender with your mouth hanging open
>Slowly shaking your head over and over
I can't die. I just can't...
>Toss up the facts
>You accept Fluttershy: You live in peace and happiness for the rest of your days
>You reject her: You die this year
>You piss her off: She rapes you in public on a bridge somewhere.
>Tough choice
>You stand up, you know what you have to do.
>Walk back over to Flutterdeath
I've seen enough, I know what I have to do.
>She nods and suddenly you're back in your bed
>Stare at the wall infront of you, which not 5 minutes ago bore the message of your doom
>Get up and get dressed
>Look outside, see that it's morning
>Look at the Calender
>December 25th - 3002 AD
>Sigh
>Head towards Fluttershy's house
>On the way there, see ponies dressed up and in festive clothing
>Goddamn Equestrian Weather. Yesterday it was sunny with not a flake of snow on the ground. Now it looks like a Whatmas Pageant.
>Continue onwards to the cottage
>Hear carollers singing
>Cheesy as fuck
>You remember what the Shy of Rapesmas Present showed you, and suddenly you feel a lot happier.
>Arrive at the cottage
>Mentally prepare yourself
>Knock twice
>Fluttershy opens the door
>"Oh! Anon! How wonderful to see you!"
>She smiles
>It fills you with happiness and fear
>Fucking Spirits
Hey... Fluttershy... Listen. I was just wondering if you'd like to uhh...
>Look past her
>Notice a huge black tome on the table
>"Y-yes, Anon?"
>She moves to block your vision
Hang on, what's that book?
>"N-NOTHING, WHAT WERE YOU GOING TO SAY?"
>Stride past her and look at the front cover
>Dream Manipulation for Dummies: A concise guide to altering sleeping patterns and creating realistic illusions.
>Feel your eye twitch
>Spin around
>Grab Fluttershy by the throat and start throttling her
FLUUUUTTEEEEEERSHYYYYYYY
>Suddenly Pinkie Pie bursts out of a closest and bounces right up to you
>She grabs your head in her hooves and looks right into your eyes, you feel like she's staring into your soul
>Nothing can prepare you for what she says next
MERRY WHATSMAS, /mlp/!!! 

The End