https://desuarchive.org/mlp/thread/39824888/#39857152

>be me chilling in apartment with Dash
>we're both reading books on the couch in silence, but cuddling
>is nice
>silece broken
>"Anon, do you think you could rape me?"
>excusemewhatthefuck.png
>Tell her wtf, and I would never do that
>"No, no, not like that, I mean like, do you think you could force yourself on me, like physically do it?"
>Tell her that's weird and go back to reading
>"...so you're not even gonna tell me?"
>no
>"no what"
>no i don't want to fucking rape you, and i don't want to talk about this
>"No, but COULD you?"
>I sigh and put my book down and rub the bridge of my nose
>ask why the fuck she's even asking me this fucked shit
>she looks embarrassed a bit
>"I dunno, I guess I was just curious, I didn't think it was that weird."
>feel kinda bad
>tell her i just feel uncomfortable with the notion
>"well i mean it's just a hypothetical, you know fetishes and shit."
>she gets a bit indignant
>"I didn't get upset when you told me you were into [insert embarrassing fetish here]"
>shrug
>fair point
>ask if she's legit interested noncon rp
>"yeah, i just don't think you can do it."
>woah, went from asking if i could to straight up saying I can't
>finally consider legitimately thinking about the logistics of raping my wife Rainbow Dash
>Reluctantly tell her I probably could if I got her pinned

>she blushes
>"hmm, you sound sure of yourself, I bet you couldn't"
>isthatachallenge.webm
>unzip dick
>"w-what are you doing?"
>raping you I guess idk
>grab dash and pick her up
>dash shakes her head
>"no no no, that doesn't count"
>let dash down
>what the fuck you mean that doesn't count?
>"you have to catch me off gaurd. It's not non consensual if I see it coming, you need to surprise me. Otherwise it's just regular fucking."
>this fucking horse
>fine
>go back to reading and cuddling
>agree that i'll do my best to make her fantasy come true
>she blushes and smiles

>ffw about 6 hours later
>dash goes outside to collect laundary from clothesline
>formulate idea
>strip down and wait along wall closest to door
>wait about 5 minutes, take time to lube up as to avoid hurting dash
>dash finally comes through door bringing in laundry from outside, basket on her back
>she doesn't see me
>opportunity spotted
>grab dash from behind
>she gasps and jumps from being startled
>try to quickly thrust self into her from behind
>tip of penis barely makes it in
>swift kick into my testicles
>i double over and cup my balls
>the pain is immeasurable
>"hah, you gotta do better than that"
>sees me on floor writhing in agony
>she realizes
>"oh shit, anon you okay?"
>no you fucking horse
>get balls on ice
>pain not ceasing
>get dressed with dash and go to Ponyville hospital
>dash feels really bad about it and won't stop apologizing
>tell her it's fine
>go to triage
>tfw Dash ruptured my testicle
>both of us too embarrassed to tell Nurse Redheart how it happened
>make up a story about me slipping on the side of the tub and smashing my balls
>pretty sure she doesn't buy it
>emergency surgery to fix it
>tfw dash no longer wants to try non con
>tfw dash literally busted my balls
>tfw I can't rape rainbow dash