GREEN   261   0
   13044 71.17 KB    682

Horny Pony Invasion

By StreamofGreen
Created: 2025-01-29 19:58:45
Updated: 2025-02-03 02:49:48
Expiry: Never
harem

  1. >Be Anon
  2. >A student at Canterlot High who's well known as a decent guy and has plenty of friends
  3. >Especially a group consisting of some of the best known girls in school
  4. >Before school you're talking with one of them, Pinkie
  5. >She's a very hyper and bubbly girl who's super friendly and cute
  6. >She'd tackled you in greeting and is now hugging you while you talked
  7. >Pinkie talks a mile a minute about her part time job, how her family back at the rock farm are doing, and everything in between
  8. >Like always, Anon has trouble keeping up and understanding it all, but does his best
  9. >After she's done talking you're always surprised how she doesn't have to gasp for air afterwards like she has infinite lung capacity or something
  10. >You pat her head and ruffle her hair which makes her giggle and smile
  11. >She has large fun bags and wide hips which you try not to stare at too much
  12. >Though sometimes she catches you off guard by teasing you or quickly making reference to her assets
  13. >Like sneaking in a quick line about herself having big breasts somewhere in her spiel like it's a way to check if you're listening
  14. >That didn't happen this time
  15. >You're pretty sure you listened as carefully as you could, and she didn't slip anything like that in
  16. >After cuddling into your side for a bit she remembers something she has to do before her first class and zips off
  17. >With nothing left to do here you move on yourself
  18. >In a empty section of hallway you see Pinkie again heading towards you like she's going to tackle you again
  19. "Did you forget something?", you ask her, but as she got closer something seemed off
  20. >She only seemed to run faster as she got closer instead of moderating her pace, and her face looked very... Predatory
  21. >You're considering your options for what you'd do when she jumps at you and wraps both her arms and legs around you
  22. >Her crotch under her skirt pressed against yours as she started aggressively making out with you
  23. >For a bit while she's sticking her tongue in your mouth and squeezing you tight with her body all you can do is wonder what's gotten into her
  24. >When you're finally able to physically react you grab her try to pull her off of you
  25. >She pretty strongly resists, but with some effort you're able to wrestle her off
  26. >Holding her by her armpits she looks at you with a very horny and disappointing face
  27. "What's the matter with you Pinkie?! What's gotten into you?!", asking in total shock as she looks at you confused
  28. >"Don't you guys normally do stuff like this?", she asks as you only get more confused
  29. "What do you mean, 'you guys'?", asking the obvious follow up question without skipping a beat
  30. >She then starts tells you, "I guess I should explain...", and then breathes in deeply as you're sure you're in for a long explanation
  31. >"I'm actually a version of Pinkie from a different world and came here through a portal. Where I'm from we're all ponies and the place is called Equestria. Does that explain everything?"
  32.  
  33. >Not really, but also is she for real?
  34. >This is just Pinkie pulling a prank on you, right?
  35. >"Come on, Nonny, let's fuck already!", she tells you with such a shamelessly horny and impatient voice
  36. "Don't say something like that so loud at school! Are you trying to get us in trouble?! Again...", you say remembering other times she's gotten you in trouble with her pulling pranks, but you can at least say none of those had anything to do with sex
  37. >She's shameless in continuing on with her antics
  38. >"But the Pinkie of this world said you've had sex with each other before and do it for fun! I want some of that! I want to know what having sex just for fun is like!", she says now in an almost whiny voice
  39. >You aren't entirely sure where to start if you even believe what she's saying is true and she's some 'other Pinkie', but you'd might as well play along because otherwise you doubt you'd get anywhere
  40. "Well, what she told you was wrong. We hadn't had sex, and we don't even have that kind of a relationship.", you say even if you feel Pinkie might feel you're saying that a little coldly
  41. You add afterwards because You felt bad about it the longer you thought about it, "We're close friends and I like her, but it doesn't go beyond that."
  42. >Her expressions processing that puzzle you until she gets a smug face that makes you worry
  43. >"You do have sex for fun here, though, right~?", she asks, clearly honing in on a specific point you didn't emphasize
  44. >You weren't sure how you should respond to that
  45. "Well, some people do, but that's besides the point!", you say wanting to steer the conversation somewhere else
  46. >Though her face gets even more smug and her smug aura mocks you after practically getting the answer she wanted
  47. >"Guess I'm just going to have to try a little harder to get what I want~.", she says before escaping your grasp and coming up to your side
  48. >Whispering in your ear, "I'll see you later, lover boy, when you'll be in me, and I'll milk you dry so good you'll be addicted~."
  49. >She then kisses your bright red cheek before starting to skip off
  50. >Though not before smugly sticking her tongue out playfully while looking back at you while lifting her skirt
  51. >Which revealed she wasn't wearing panties which showed you everything
  52. >Looking down at your crotch there was a wet stain where Pinkie's crotch was on you, and it almost looked like you pissed yourself
  53. >You went the bathroom and changed to a spare pair of pants you had that was meant more for stuff like getting splashed with mud
  54. >Though what just happened stayed playing on repeat in a loop in your mind
  55. >It kind of seemed like something Pinkie might do, but also it hardly felt real
  56. >Questions swirling in your mind
  57. >Why would Pinkie pull a prank like that, and did she actually want to fuck you?
  58. >Also possibly the most important question
  59. >Is she really running around school right now without panties?
  60.  
  61. >Though before you could try to follow up on any of that with Pinkie, you had to go to your first class
  62. >Which was PE
  63. >It feels good to get that out of the way early in the day, and usually helps you be fully awake for the rest of the day
  64. >Yet sometimes if it's an especially intense PE class you'll be left feeling worn out with no energy
  65. >Thankfully you have this class with one of your friends, Rainbow Dash
  66. >She's a great athlete and proud of it, but she's also a good coach who's good at motivating you
  67. >Although she likes to brag she's never condescending about how much more athletic she is than you
  68. >Going around the track she stays in front of you and encourages you to push yourself while also something playfully teasing a little
  69. >She's relatively short, and has a relatively flat, petite body
  70. >You wouldn't dare bring this up around her
  71. >Knowing you'd have to be suicidal to say within earshot of her that she has a flat chest in particular
  72. >Yet running behind her, her firm little ass begs you to stare at it
  73. >Her tight fitting athletic shorts only make it take more willpower to not let your eyes rest there
  74. >After PE is over she heads back into the girls locker room to change out of her PE clothes
  75. >Then as you're heading to the boy's locker room you suddenly see Rainbow calling to you from around a corner
  76. >You just saw her go into the locker room, and Rainbow now is already in normal clothes
  77. >It reminds you of the strange encounter with Pinkie as you go over there simply unable to ignore your curiosity with it
  78. >Once you're around the corner she pushes you to the ground and gets on top of you
  79. >Rubbing herself on your crotch while looking down at you smugly
  80. >"You know the best when you see it, and that's why you came right over so quickly.", she says proudly
  81. >"Now, how about you tell me how sexy I am, and maybe I'll let you cum in me~.", then added with extra smugness
  82. >Now you know something strange is going on here
  83. "What's going on? Are you going to say you're a pony too?", you ask her as she seemed perplexed, but not for the reason a normal person would
  84. >"Well, yes, I am from Equestria, but who got to you first?! It should have been me! Also why aren't you slobbering over me begging me to let you fuck me?! I'm the best, and a highly decorated Wonderbolt!", she protests and you have no idea what she's talking about
  85. >Though you start somewhere
  86. "It was Pinkie first, and I thought she was just pranking me when she said she came in through a portal from a pony world-", you say before being cut off by Raindbow
  87. >"Did you do it?!", she impatiently asked
  88. "No! I don't know where you got your ideas about the human world, but we don't have sex so casually here.", you tell her
  89. >"Why not?! Also you'd done it with Rainbow before, and are in a relationship with her aren't you?!", she asks as you're starting to see a pattern
  90.  
  91. "Pinkie also thought that, and It wasn't true there either. I'm just friends with Rainbow Dash here.", you reply trying to stay calm
  92. >"Sex friends?", Rainbow asks seemingly unwilling to back down from sex easily
  93. >You're trying to think of how to respond to that, and considering giving in with you willpower fading
  94. >Her crotch rubbing on you making your lower brain practically screaming at you to just put it in her
  95. >Though the sounds of approaching people practically makes you jump out of your skin
  96. >This apparent 'pony' Rainbow at least has the sense to not do this with an audience
  97. >She quickly gets off of you, and you move to go to your next class before your later
  98. >Though before you go she whispers in your ear, "We'll pick this back up later, you'll admit how sexy I am, and you'll be begging for more~."
  99. >You rush getting back into your regular clothes as a result of being late to start
  100. >After hurrying enough you get to your next class in time, but needing a moment to catch your breathes
  101. >Fluttershy uses a napkin to wipe your forehead before asking you with concern, "Was PE rough on you Anon?"
  102. "Thanks for asking, Fluttershy, but I'm okay. After I just catch my breath. Got a little delayed getting here and had to rush to be on time.", you explain while leaving out unnecessary details
  103. >You have biology class with her, and things go normally
  104. >She sprinkles in talking about the animals as the shelter while helping you understand what the class is going over
  105. >You could understand it on your own, but Fluttershy really helps make it easier
  106. >Her kind and caring approach also makes you feel all warm and fuzzy inside
  107. >She's just so sweet and adorable
  108. >After class it's time for your first break
  109. >Flutteryshy goes off on her own, but when you turn to do the same a soft delicate hand grabs yours
  110. >Like you thought, despite having just left Fluttershy was holding your hand, and leading you somewhere
  111. >She takes you to a secluded spot, and you can already tell where this is going
  112. >Leaning back against the wall she pulls you forward to lead you into pinning her against the wall
  113. >"I-if you don't mind... Could you please have sex with me?", she asks very politely despite what she's asking
  114. >When you look like you're trying to resist the urge to comply she asks, "Please..."
  115. >Looking into your eyes with such adorable pleading eyes you could practically feel your heart breaking just from the thought of denying her
  116. >You remind yourself you shouldn't as you try to resist harder
  117. >"Please?...", she asks again with such a pleading voice
  118. >You couldn't look into those puppy eyes anymore and deny her
  119. >Trying to look away it was like the image of those pleading eyes was burned into your mind
  120. >"Please?...", you heard her say again, and you couldn't take it anymore
  121. "Okay...", you say, and the elated smile on her face made you wonder why you even tried to resist
  122.  
  123. >You undo your pants, and she helps aim your dick at her pussy with her dress hiked up
  124. >She wasn't wearing panties either
  125. >The presumably pony Fluttershy lets herself slide down onto your shaft while wrapping herself around you
  126. >Entering she she lets out a little bit of a moan before biting her lip and trying to stay quiet
  127. >Her pussy clamps down on you, and from there your instincts take over
  128. >Thrusting into her against the wall hoping nobody would come and catch you doing this
  129. >"This is the best... This is really the best~...", she says trying to keep her voice down while tightening her arms and legs around you
  130. >You thrust into her more and feel yourself getting close to cumming
  131. "I'm... I'm going to cum...", you tell her and her arms and legs become like a vice grip
  132. >"Don't you dare pull out!", she tells you sharply and sternly
  133. >You don't even have time to consider disobeying that before you cum in her
  134. >She kisses you while you keep cumming in her, and kisses you even deeper in the afterglow
  135. >You feel weak afterwards and it's more like she has you pinned rather than the other way around as she cradles your head in her chest
  136. >It crosses your mind that you were never in control here
  137. >"Sweet, Anon... You'll indulge me again next time, won't you, sweety~?", she asks you a leading question, and you can't help but fall right into it
  138. "Of course. Anything for you.", you respond like it was the only thing you could have said
  139. >She kisses you again and strokes your hair while burying your face in her chest
  140. >After a bit of this she lets herself down, cleans both herself and you up, and then sends you on your way blowing a kiss
  141. >The rest in between then and being in your next class after the break is like a fatigue muddled blur
  142. >You felt like a mind controlled zombie even though you were pretty sure she didn't literally control your mind
  143. >The next class was shop class with Applejack
  144. >She seems to turn her nose up when you sat next to her
  145. >"Ya'll smell rather sweaty there, hard day at PE?", you then realize how you must smell from what actually just happened
  146. >You take some deodorant out of your backpack and use it, hopefully before she might realize what the smell really is
  147. >After that you help Applejack with making something she intends to use back at her family farm
  148. >It's a larger project you've been working on all week, but you're sure you'll get a good grade on it when it's finished
  149. >After a while of doing that you're fully out of the mental fog you were in earlier
  150. >Though the idea lingers in the back of your mind that you'll get jumped by a 'pony' Applejack before long
  151. >If she's forceful at all you know you won't stand any chance at resisting her
  152. >Your lower half was ready for it, but your upper half worried
  153.  
  154. >A part of you wanted to just stay with human Applejack as long as possible if it was true that the pony Applejack would show up once she left
  155. >Though you could just stay glued to her the rest of the day
  156. >Sure enough, once shop class ended you had to part ways with Applejack, and once she was out of sight you got lassoed from the other direction
  157. >Pulled in by a different Applejack who then tied you up around the chest and arms with the rope before carrying you over her shoulder
  158. >Taking you out behind some bushes and setting you on the ground
  159. >Looking down at you with a predatory grin and licking her lips before saying, "Time to ride a cowboy~."
  160. >Pulls off your pants so hard your were worried about them getting ripped before mounting you
  161. >Your dick sliding into her under her jean skirt effortlessly
  162. >Her hands on your shoulders as she started bouncing hard and fast on your hips
  163. >Her predatory pleasure filled look gazing into your eyes made you squirm with pleasure under her on top of the feeling of her powerful pussy gripping you
  164. >"This is by far the best rodeo I've ever done~!", she tells you while riding you even harder
  165. >You doubt any bull in a rodeo has ever been ridden this hard while tied up, and definitely not this way
  166. >You started to worry if your hips would survive
  167. >You also worried about being late to your next class till you realized it was lunch
  168. >Almost on cue your stomach grumbles
  169. >Applejack notices this and produces an apple from somewhere
  170. >"You hungry? Have, and apple on my, sugar cube."
  171. >She then shoved the apple in your mouth which then more felt like a gag than something you could eat
  172. >Applejack then rode you while you were tied up with an apple in your mouth like a ball gag till you came in her
  173. >You definitely couldn't say anything about it in your state
  174. >She trembled and grabbed the ropes around you tightly while milking you dry
  175. >After both your orgasms passed she untied you and cleaned you up before letting you keep the apple to actually eat
  176. >"This world's Applejack was right about how great this is. Doin' this for pleasure instead of just makin' babies. You'd be fine with doing some more of this some time right?"
  177. "Sure, why not?", you say unsure if it mattered what you said or not
  178. >Though her implying Applejack told them she'd had sex with you definitely also followed a pattern that was impossible to ignore
  179. >"Great, I'll be seeing you 'round, sugar cube~.", she said flirtatiously before giving you a kiss and sending you on your way much like the pony Fluttershy did
  180. >You end up eating the apple while walking and checking the time
  181. >That stuff with Applejack took most of your lunch break, so you just head to your next class a little early
  182. >The next class was a science class with Twilight
  183. >You sit down somewhat absentmindedly before realizing she was dressed different
  184.  
  185. >She was dressed less nerdy with more of a normal dress rather than the semi school uniform dress she normally wears, and didn't have her glasses on
  186. "Did you lose your glasses?", you asks her as she seems embarrassed about it
  187. >"I'm just trying out contacts...", she says while looking down and away bashfully
  188. >Once you move on from that the class goes by pretty normally
  189. >There were some parts where Twilight was seeming forgetful about the material
  190. >Though you wrote it off as her not reading as well because she needs to adjust to the contacts
  191. >Besides her being bashful about not wearing glasses she seems more outgoing less socially awkward than usual
  192. >Maybe trying something new has helped her come out of her shell?
  193. >She's very excited about reading ahead in the text book and learning at her own pace though
  194. >Which definitely tracks with her and makes it seem more like her normal self
  195. >Though there was the looming possibility of what would happen after class
  196. >Which came to pass after class ended, of course
  197. >Twilight stayed behind, and the other Twilight was waiting for you outside the classroom
  198. >She grabbed your arm and pulled you along with her into the library like an overexcited whirlwind
  199. >Taking you to a deep and secluded corner of the Library before starting to make out with you and pulling down your pants
  200. >After all that's happened you end up just going along with it
  201. >Pinning her against the bookshelf you slide your exposed dick right into her as she wraps herself around you and makes out with you more
  202. >Her pussy is extremely tight compared to what you felt before, and she has a hard time suppressing her moans despite trying her best
  203. >You almost worry about getting caught, but it's not a time when people are normally here
  204. >In fact, you don't think you saw anyone at the desk even, probably on break
  205. >You push that stuff out of your mind to fully immerse yourself in fucking the 'pony' version of Twilight
  206. >Thrusting into her tight pussy like a jackhammer while feeling like you've gotten the hang of it
  207. >Then bottoming out in her and blowing your load into her without hesitation
  208. >She kissed you extra deep as a way to quiet herself as she practically screamed a moan into your mouth, and her pussy clamped down on you like a vice grip
  209. >After you both wound down from it she broke the kiss with a look of pure bliss on her face
  210. >This was when you truly noticed she was wearing glasses
  211. >Has the same clothes the Twilight you're used to would wear too...
  212. >"Isn't gr-great how us 'pony world' people just have sex like this with no strings attached?", she says awkwardly as it becomes more obvious to you this isn't really the pony version at all
  213. >With a deep red blush she then tells you, "Unless you insisted on officially being my boyfriend... Then I suppose I'd allow that..."
  214. >You just came inside the human Twilight...
  215. >Wanting to tell yourself you should have exercised more caution, but it feels a little late for that
  216.  
  217. "You're not the pony version, are you?", You ask her despite knowing the answer to see how she'd react
  218. >She looks away and stammers while tightening her legs around you more
  219. >"O-of course I'm the pony version! I'm a horny sex crazed pervert like the rest!", she says like she thought that would convince you
  220. "How did you even know about them? Nobody else seems to.", you ask her more pointedly
  221. >Twilight seems to reluctantly accept she can't fool you into actually thinking she's the pony version now
  222. >"Fine... I've been spying on you, and saw you with the other pony versions. The rest of our friend group have been in contact with our pony versions, but the others probably don't know what their other self has been up to."
  223. >Your dick starts to re-harden from still being in her
  224. "Could I pull out now so we can talk with less distraction?", you ask her
  225. >"No! Don't do that!", she insists while re-tightening her legs around you which forces you to stay in her to the hilt
  226. "Fine...", you say before moving on to the next question you'd ask, "Why would the actual pony version of you stay in the class instead of doing what you're doing now, and why would you be okay skipping class?"
  227. >"I don't know why the other pony version are acting like they are, but my pony version was more interested in studying our world than sex...", she first explains
  228. >"Which is a shame, getting a chance to live out your fantasies doesn't come by every day.", she adds with more of a blush and kisses you
  229. >"Speaking of which... Can I have your boxers? I'll give you my panties in exchange?", asking shamelessly as you have no willpower to refuse
  230. "Okay...", you say with reservation as she lets go of you with her legs and you separate from each other
  231. >She slides of her purple stripped panties that were hanging off one of her ankles and hands it to you, and you fully take off your pants to hand her your boxes before putting back on your pants without underwear
  232. >You're the one to end up cleaning up the mess left on the floor to make sure no 'evidence' is left behind
  233. >Though you're more worried about what might happen with Twilight later on because you came in her, but maybe you'd talk with her about that later
  234. >"So... About you being my boyfriend?...", she asks you more insistently as if demanding an answer
  235. "You'd want me too even with the stuff going on with the other girls? Errr... Their pony versions I guess.", you say feeling like you'd be cheating on her if you say you'll be her boyfriend
  236. >She thinks about it a bit seeming angry before conceding on something
  237. >"I'm the one asking you first! but... I supposed it could cause problems... Even if we aren't a couple publicly, please say you're my boyfriend... I've wanted it longer than you probably know."
  238. >You sigh before indulging her
  239. "You've got it, I'm your boyfriend, Twilight.", you say before giving her a kiss
  240. >Twilight nearly faints from being overwhelmed despite having casually had sex with you earlier
  241.  
  242. >You catch her in your arms before realizing you're definitely late for your last class
  243. >Propping Twilight against the bookshelf and making sure she wouldn't fall before running off
  244. >Making a quick comment about being late as you sped off
  245. >The last class was a theater class with Rarity at the school theater
  246. >With the final class project being putting on a school play
  247. >When you get there Rarity is waiting for you tapping her foot angrily
  248. >"You're late, Anonymous...", she says angrily, sounding like she's the teacher and using your full name instead of just saying 'Anon'
  249. "I know, I know, I'm sorry... I just got, held up...", you tell her as she doesn't really stay mad
  250. >Other students in the class are reading the script for the play and rehearsing lines in a free form manner
  251. >Rarity then takes you into a the room with the costumes before telling you, "I'll need to take some measurements~..."
  252. >Saying so with some excitement, and saying so despite Rarity have already taken measurements for your costume earlier
  253. >She takes out the tape measure with a lewd and predatory look on her face that made you blush
  254. >Then started getting very handsy with you and feeling your inner thighs a lot
  255. >More pretending to take measurements than actually doing so
  256. >Your phone is halfway pushed out of your pocket and shows unread messages
  257. >You quickly pull it out of your pocket and check them
  258. >Among messes from other girls you have messages from Rarity
  259. >Saying she went home early feeling sick, and you'd have to do your best today without her
  260. >Which meant this 'Rarity' with you had to be the pony version
  261. >"No phones in class, Darling~.", she says before forcing your phone back into your pocket
  262. >She then fiddles with the tape measure a bit more before getting a devilish grin
  263. >"I think I'll have to remove these ridiculous 'pants' to get proper measurements~."
  264. >Without further notice she grabs the waistline of your pants and yanks them down
  265. >Causing your boner to drop down in front of her face as she stared and grinned
  266. >"Now I think I'll 'measure it' with my mouth~.", she says before starting with a kiss to your tip
  267. >Then taking the rest of your length into her mouth and even into her throat a little
  268. >Expertly starting to suck you off
  269. >You squirmed and your legs felt weak as you practically struggled to stay standing
  270. >Desperately hoping nobody else would decide to come into there
  271. >When she notices you're about to cum she immediately takes her mouth off of you, and grips the base of your shaft hard with her hand to stop you from cumming
  272. >"You don't just cum down a proper ladies throat, and if you cum on my face it could ruin my hair.", she tells you matter of factly
  273. >Though she looks up at you with a more sly grin
  274. >"Yet, you can cum inside me later~.", she says first before adding, "After we go on a proper date~."
  275. >She then kisses your tip teasingly while still forcing you to not cum before pulling your pants back up
  276.  
  277. >Your balls ached for release as she deliberately teased you and left you wanting
  278. >"Let's have our date this weekend, Darling~. I'm sure you can't wait~.", she said flirtatiously
  279. >Her technique was definitely on point, because you really did want it pretty badly right now
  280. >Though Rarity took you with her back to join the rest of the class and practiced for the play like everything was normal
  281. >When class and the school day itself ends Rarity blows you a kiss, and saunters off making sure to show off her elegant ass to you
  282. >With no 'other Rarity' here to jump you, it looks like the school day is finally over
  283. >It was long, not in a bad way per say, but very long
  284. >Yet, you couldn't shake the feeling the day wasn't quite over yet
  285. >As you walked home you felt like you were being followed
  286. >Which turned out to be true when Pinkie jumped out in front of you from behind
  287. >Both of them in fact
  288. >Looking the same, posing the same, and wearing the same smug lustful expressions as they blocked your path
  289. >"Hey, Nonny! Didn't think you'd just go home without playing with me, did you?", one of them says teasingly in a lustful manner that made it obvious what she meant by 'playing'
  290. >The other Pinkie giggles before chiming in, "We got to talking, and thought it'd be fun to play a 'game' with you~."
  291. "What kind of game?", you ask them as they both grinned from ear to ear
  292. >"Obviously one of us is the human Pinkie, and the other is the pony Pinkie. Which is which? You've got to guess!", one of them answers
  293. >The other smiles deviously before adding, "Guess right and you get a prize! Guess wrong and we give you a punishment!"
  294. >You're about to ask about that when they cut you off to answer in their new routine of being in synch with each other
  295. >"If you guess right you get to have sex with both of us-", and then the other continued from there without skipping a beat, "-If you guess wrong we'll both fuck you~."
  296. >You raise an eyebrow
  297. "Isn't that the same either way?", you ask as they both giggle like you're being naive
  298. >"I assure you they're very different~. Be careful with your choice, and you won't have to find out what the punishment version is like. Even if I might enjoy that one a little too much~.", one of them answers with a predatory grin while the other looks at them with a bit of unease
  299. >How would you go about trying to really differentiate them?
  300. "Do I get something like a question round?", you ask them hoping asking the right questions can help you know which is which
  301. >They don't look like they'll give you that
  302. >"Geez, Nonny, I know I wanted it to be a game, but shouldn't you actually be able to tell?", they both say at once
  303. "It's not fair to me if you're both going to act the same.", you say as both of them seem insulted by this, but one of them more than the other
  304. >"Hey, I'm not like the sex starved pervert over there! Sure, I may have healthy urges, but she's on a whole different level!", one of them says as you point to them
  305.  
  306. >They were also the one to be uneasy when the other one said the comment about the 'punishment'
  307. "You've got to be the human Pinkie, right?!", you say with a bit of desperation in your voice
  308. >Though the one you're pointing at has an expression like you fucked up, and the other has a dark and even more predatory gaze
  309. "Wrong, Nonny~. I'm the human Pinkie~.", the other one says as it's clear you're going to learn what the 'punishment' is like
  310. >You feel like you should be seriously worried about it, but it's Pinkie...
  311. >Fun loving, playful, and sweet Pinkie
  312. >"Since you guessed wrong, it's time for me to show you what my feelings for you are really like... The hard way.", she says while flanking you on one side while getting the other to follow her lead
  313. >Taking you to a side area out of view of the street before stripping you down, and undressing themselves
  314. >They then force you to the ground with human Pinkie under you in a mating press, and pony Pinkie on top of you holding you in place
  315. >Big Pinkie fun bags against your chest and back while a greedy pink pussy gripped your cock
  316. >Pony Pinkie moved into you to make you thrust into human Pinkie while she held your shoulders tightly
  317. >You tried to thrust yourself to go at your own pace, but pony Pinkie always stepped it up to go faster and harder than you were
  318. >When you were about to cum you try to hold it in, and not repeat the same mistake as with human Twilight
  319. >Maybe you shouldn't have actually came inside the pony versions you did either, but with the human versions you know it feels more 'real' with more real potential consequences
  320. >"What's my favorite type of pie, Nonny~?", she asks you while digging her nails into your shoulders as it seemed random and out of place until the actual answer entered your mind
  321. >Cream pie
  322. >She'd made literal cream pies before and even done the clown act of throwing pie tins filled with whipped cream before when saying it was her favorite
  323. >Did she mean this all along?
  324. "Cream pies...", you actually say after the realization fully hit
  325. >"That's right Nonny~! Also your expression is so cute, and yes, I was saying I wanted you to cum inside me the whole time! So do it!"
  326. >You gasp for breath while still trying to hold it back while your balls feel like they might explode
  327. >"Make my womb a party where all your little swimmers are invited, Nonny~."
  328. >Despite your best efforts you explosively cum inside her
  329. >In fact, trying to hold it back probably only made you cum more inside her when you let loose
  330. >She screamed a moan with a look of pure bliss on her face, and then kissed you passionately while hugging her arms around your shoulders
  331. >"That's a good boy, Nonny~. Now just stay right there nice and deep to make sure it all goes in where it should~.", she says as it sound like she's trying to get pregnant
  332. >The look of worry about it makes her grin even more while holding you possessively
  333.  
  334. >"Are you worried about my daddy calling a shotgun wedding if I get pregnant~? Maybe we'll just have to see what happens~.", adding before the pony Pinkie whispers in your ear
  335. >"I've had my own mentally unstable moments, but I think you should be careful of this one...", whispering as softly as she can in your ear
  336. >"I heard that!", human Pinkie yells as pony Pinkie freezes up
  337. >"I'm just playing! Though maybe you could try calming down a little... He loves you, after all!", pony Pinkie says to diffuse the situation
  338. >"Do you love me, Nonny?", human Pinkie asks you with an eye twitch as her hair seems to supernaturally flatten a bit
  339. "Of course I love you, Pinkie! You're my lovely, bubbly, sweet, and playful ball of sunshine! Every time I see you it's guaranteed to make my day brighter!", you say and give her a passionate kiss to emphasize your point
  340. >The movement forward to kiss her makes your sensitive dick inside her twitch as you can almost feel pressure from your cum plugged up inside her, and it all sends a shiver up your spine
  341. >Her hair goes back to full curly, and she has a wide happy smile on her face
  342. >"You've got another round in you, don't you, Nonny~?", she asks you excitedly
  343. >Though pony Pinkie clears her throat
  344. >"Oh, right! Wouldn't want to leave my partner in crime, Pinkie, out in the cold! We'll have to have our second round another time, but for now... Time to swap places~!", she said before what happened next is a blur of Pinkie
  345. >Human Pinkie somehow slides out from under you and gets on top of you while pony Pinkie slides off and under you so fluidly and in synch it's like a magic act
  346. >Your dick went from being inside human Pinkie to being inside pony Pinkie so fast you hardly even felt any in-between part of having been pulled out
  347. >"I don't know how much you've got left in those nice balls, but make sure to give pony me a nice cream pie too~!", human Pinkie says before controlling your thrusts much like pony Pinkie had
  348. >Pony Pinkie moans and kisses you while tightly hugging her arms around your shoulders
  349. >"I think you'd have a wonderful time in Equestria if you come to visit our world some time~!", she said before kissing you again
  350. >Human Pinkie has her own thoughts about that
  351. >"I think he's fine staying here with me...", with a slight glare at pony Pinkie
  352. >"You should come to our world too, of course! I'm sure you'd love to meet the pony versions of your family too!", she says as if to save face
  353. >"Oh, that does sound fun!", human Pinkie responds as you're not sure what she's really thinking
  354. >After being left sensitive from before you aren't even able to try to hold back from cumming as well as you did before
  355. >Just suddenly blasting your load before you even knew you were close
  356. >Filling her up, even if not quite as much as with human Pinkie
  357. "Hey, uhmmm, do you think pony girls in our world could get pregnant from a guy like me?", you had to ask after your Pinkie brought up pregnancy
  358.  
  359. >"I don't know~! I think I'd want to say 'no' since we're actually totally different species, but it's never been tried before and my anatomy is like a human right now with magic, so... I don't know!", an answer which didn't give you any confidence
  360. >"Guess we'll have to find out~. Could you imagine if you got two Pinkies pregnant at the same time~?", human Pinkie said playfully
  361. >"I'm not sure you should joke about that, Pinkie. I haven't been here long, and even I know pregnancy is a lot more serious here than in Equestria...", pony Pinkie told her
  362. >"My family adheres to older ways, I'm sure they'd love it if I got pregnant! Mom is always saying how she got pregnant with my first sibling younger than me!", Pinkie says as you're not sure if she's serious
  363. >You weren't going to ask either
  364. >After a bit of both of them kissing you all over your face they both get off of you and let you get cleaned up and dressed while putting their own clothes back on
  365. >Though they had a bit of an argument about who's bits of clothing were who's because they looked the same
  366. >Human Pinkie also made mention of how there was only one pair of panties and pony Pinkie readily admitted she'd gone without them
  367. >After that pony Pinkie offers to escort you home while human Pinkie goes off on her own
  368. >"I already know where Nonny lives~.", she gave as her reason to not go with and let pony Pinkie escort you home
  369. Pony Pinkie looks worried before you sigh and tell her, "She's been over to my place before, for completely innocent visits."
  370. You make sure human Pinkie is out of earshot before you whisper in pony Pinkie's ear, "I'm honestly shocked to find out about this side of her..."
  371. >Pony Pinkie nods in a sagely manner and pats your back supportively
  372. >"Well, let's head to your place! You can lean on me for support if you want, Nonny~!", she says excitedly as you take her up on her offer
  373. >Your legs felt like weak jello on the rest of the way back home
  374. >Once inside your house your parents greet you and especially Pinkie
  375. >"Oh, Pinkie! I didn't know you were coming over, nice to see you! How are you doing?", your mom casually makes small talk
  376. >"I'm doing fine! Though Nonners had a very tiring day at school, so I wanted to make sure he got home safely!", she said as your mom responded by patting her on the head and thanking her
  377. >"I think that nickname you have for him is so cute. Sometimes I'm tempted to call him myself, but I'm sure it'd just embarrass him if his mom said it.", your mom said as you kind of felt she was right that you'd be embarrassed
  378. >"How's your dad doing, Pinkie? He's a very busy man, I know, but I don't think it'd kill him to play a round of two of golf some time.", your dad asks her
  379. >Pinkie stammers not actually knowing much about human Pinkie's dad before saying, "He's doing fine! I'm not sure when he'll have free time, but I'll pass along the message about having a round of golf!"
  380.  
  381. >Your dad nods with approval before returning to his dinner at the table
  382. >Then your mom tells you dinner is ready, and invites Pinkie to join and have some too
  383. >She looks like she seriously considered it, but politely declined before excusing herself and leaving
  384. >You have dinner like normal, and head to bed
  385. >You worry your parents would have questions, but thankfully pony Pinkie didn't make your parents suspicious
  386. >After that you get ready for bed and go to sleep
  387. >Wondering what tomorrow might bring as you drift off to dreamland
  388. >You come into a very vivid dream with Luna
  389. >It's immediately obvious to you this isn't vice principal Luna, not even a dream version of her
  390. >This Luna wears an elegant dark blue dress with a moon theme like royalty with a black tiara to match
  391. >"My apologies if I've made a mistake, as I've never tried to visit the dream of a resident outside my realm. Art thou this 'Anonymous' human I've heard much about? If so, Princess Twilight had much to say about thou, as well as her friends.", she first says
  392. You politely nod in response before saying, "Yes, I'm Anonymous, but I prefer 'Anon'."
  393. >Then properly introducing herself, "I'm princess Luna, princess of the night and dreams. If thou find it acceptable, I would like to enter your world and partake in your human world activities."
  394. "That's fine, and I'm not a king or anything in my world. I'm actually a common citizen. Nobody from your world really needs my permission to come over.", you explain to her
  395. >You kind of feel like you're opening the floodgates saying that, but it's not like you could stop anyone from there coming here anyway
  396. >"Interesting, and what of my counterpart in your world?", Luna asks
  397. "She's vice principal of the school I attend. In case the term 'vice principal' isn't familiar she's mainly in charge of enforcing school rules and handling unruly students, with this she's stern but fair.", you explain to her
  398. >"That sounds like me, but...", she says while starting to blush before continuing
  399. >"Do you have, 'relations' with my counterpart in your world?", she asks as you felt awkward about how you'd answer, but honesty had to be the best policy here
  400. "No... In fact, that wouldn't be allowed. Mainly on concerns that a relationship between a student and school staff would introduce favoritism or be the result of the school staff abusing their authority."
  401. >The blush leaves her face with clear disappointment on her face as she says, "Truly disappointing, but I suppose that makes sense..."
  402. >Though that didn't stop her from immediately pivoting to, "Wouldst thou want to, regardless of said rules?"
  403. >She didn't even wait for you to respond to that, but your facial reaction may have told her 'yes'
  404.  
  405. >"Let us do a little role playing, I shall let thou's sub-conscious bestow upon me my counterpart's outfit, and thus I shall pretend to be her in a relationship with thou.", she said before her outfit shifted and morphed to take the shape of Luna's formal blouse and pants
  406. >She then approaches before holding up your chin in a dominant fashion to make you look up at her
  407. >"Thou hast behaved quite beneath your station...", she says as you can't help saying something about it
  408. "Uhmmm, I don't mean to be rude, but you're talking in a very antiquated fashion for our world...", you say as she doesn't seem shocked by this
  409. >"I also get this criticism in my own kingdom, tis a side effect of being banished for as long as I was. Let me try this again using more contemporary speech.", she says before clearing he throat and setting up making you look up at her into her eyes again
  410. >"You've been a very naughty boy, Anon...", she says in a somehow stern and flirtations manner at the same time
  411. You blush and hard swallow before playing along, "What exactly did I do wrong, mistress?"
  412. >"You've neglected my needs, and ignored my feelings...", she said while concentrating hard like she's tapping into something
  413. >She then kisses you and starts making out with you while holding you close
  414. >During the make out session she starts making mention of you spending time with her while acting cold
  415. >Almost like it was actually vice principal Luna talking
  416. >Making you feel really confused about what's going on and what kind of dream it is
  417. >Your mind starts to get foggy and your sense dull as the dream falls apart before ending
  418. >Going to black as you realize you've woken up, and just still have your eyes closed
  419. >Still having clear memory of the dream you have no idea what to think about it or if it could've actually been real in any way
  420. >Though you knew there was no sense worrying about it, and it'd be probably be best to just move on like it was nothing more than a strange dream
  421. >So you get up and get ready for a new day at school
  422. >You'd definitely get more shenanigans like the previous day, but it'd be better to just roll with the punches instead of worry
  423. >On your way to school you see Rainbow run up to you, and you think your 'roll with the punches' mindset will be put in practice sooner than you thought
  424. >Since you're positive this is the pony Rainbow since human rainbow either sleeps in and rushes to school at the last second, or would already be practicing in the field
  425. >As much as she's your friend it wouldn't be normal for her to intercept you on your way to school just to say 'hi'
  426. >Then it gets more intense than that as Applejack makes her own appearance
  427. >"Ready for another rodeo, sugar cube?", she says as it becomes clear this is the pony Applejack
  428. >"Hey! I was here first, and you've done him already when I got interrupted! Get in line or wait for your turn later!", Rainbow retorts as Applejack looks down at her withing a taunting smug grin
  429.  
  430. >Applejack puffs out her chest close to Rainbow's face to point out Rainbow's short height, and small chest
  431. >"I'm sure that strapping young man there would prefer a roll in the hay with a real woman.", Applejack said putting emphasis on 'real'
  432. >She looks down at Rainbow who's already getting red in the face (cutely) before adding, "What's with your human version's body anyway? You look like a little girl!"
  433. >This is obviously getting under Rainbow's skin
  434. >"I'll have you know I'm 'lithe' and 'athletic'! Unlike back home when we could actually compete at running, I could run circles around you lumbering fat human body now!", she retorts angrily
  435. >Applejack gets a little grumpy at being called 'fat', and lifts up Rainbow by her armpits
  436. >"Looks like little Dashie is getting a little grumpy. Maybe she needs to put down for a nap?", she said condescendingly as it looks like they're about to come to blows
  437. >You step in to try and diffuse things
  438. "Alright, ladies, let's just take a step back and try to let cooler heads prevail.", you say as they both look at you like they want you to butt out
  439. "A bit of banter is one thing, but I think things are getting a little too heated. You're friends after all, and neither of you are getting any if you start brawling in the street here.", after saying this Applejack begrudgingly puts Rainbow down
  440. >"I may have gone a bit too far with my teasing... I'm sorry.", Applejack said with her head turned down covering her face with her cowboy hat
  441. >"I'm sorry I called you fat too... You're all muscle and no fat. I was just angry.", Rainbow admits which must have been hard knowing her pride even if it's not the same Rainbow you know particularly well
  442. >You nod at them approvingly as they make up, but then look to you expectantly
  443. >"So, what now?", they both say almost in sync with each other
  444. >Thinking about it for a bit despite how absurd what you were about to say might have seemed as little as two days ago
  445. "Well... It wouldn't be fair to keep Rainbow left hanging, and I'll see Applejack later after shop class.", you say as Rainbow beams with excitement
  446. >"How about you tell me how sexy I am before we start~?", she says while puffing out her flat chest proudly
  447. >Applejack concedes and turns to leave, but not before telling you, "Alright, I'll see you later then. You'd better not tire yourself out too much before my turn."
  448. >With just you and pony Rainbow, you take her off to the side before starting with complying with her request
  449. "You're extremely sexy, Dashie. You have such a firm and perfectly proportioned ass, what's called a 'delicious flat chest', and your smug pride only makes everything else about you that much better.", you say trying your best
  450. >Though you don't think she particularly appreciated you admitting she's flat even if you phrased it as a positive
  451. >She still blushed profusely before saying, "L-let's just get this show on the road then!"
  452.  
  453. >She strips off her athletic shorts as it becomes even more apparent that it's a common theme for the pony versions to not wear underwear
  454. >Then strips off your pants before jumping at you as you're forced to catch her in your arms
  455. >Holding her portable body by the thighs while she held onto your shoulders
  456. >Her extremely tight pussy gripping you while you thrust into her
  457. >Though she taunts you to go faster
  458. >You do her best, but it never seems to be fast enough for her
  459. >'faster', 'harder', 'about 20% faster AND harder', are just a few of the ways she teased and taunted you to try and get you to thrust into her faster
  460. >Good thing you didn't have PE every day, because this would likely leave you burnt out for it
  461. >When she felt you were going to cum, she wore a smug face before telling you, "You want to cum inside Rainbow Dash, don't you~?"
  462. >You take your hand off her thighs and quickly wrap your arms around you as best they could despite struggling to reach all the way around you
  463. >Squeezing her with the strongest embrace you could and she wrapped her legs around you right before you blew your load in her
  464. >A look of pure bliss on her face as her cute little legs twitched at your sides
  465. >The thought occurs to you she really is portable and you could probably take her wherever you wanted right now
  466. >Though instead you go to set her back down
  467. >At least if she'd let you
  468. >She clings to you saying, "Don't do that, not yet!"
  469. You chuckle before telling her, "I would, but I'll be late for school if I just stay here and keep fucking you. There'll be more later."
  470. >"You promise?", she says with some skepticism as you can't help but just think she's cute
  471. "Promise", you say making sure to sound as confident and sure about it as you could
  472. >With this she lets you set her back down and you both get cleaned up
  473. >Though there was something special about seeing her slide her tight athletic shorts up over her creampie after making sure it wouldn't leak (too much)
  474. >After being distracted by that you rush to get to school unsure how long exactly that 'detour' took
  475. >When you arrive at school you notice you have a bit of time to spare
  476. >Yet the craziness showed no signs of slowing down
  477. >You see what looks like principal Celestia in an undersized top with no bra, and a short skirt trying to talk to students like she's one of them
  478. >Going full, 'how do you do, fellow kids?'
  479. >You even think you overhear her ask if they've seen you and call you her boyfriend
  480. >Then you're unsure if to think the day is saved or not when the real principal Celestia shows up
  481. >Because of her yelling you hear her perfectly clearly
  482. >"Is this some kind of joke?! Whoever you are, to my office, NOW!", the real principal yells to the impostor pretending to be a student and drags them off by the ear
  483. >While the regular students who witnessed this stand dumbfounded and clearly wonder if there were secretly hardcore drugs in whatever they last ate
  484.  
  485. >After that you were starting to think Celestia would handle it all herself, and you wouldn't have to get involved
  486. >Just when you were starting to think that the intercom buzzes to life
  487. >"Anonymous, please come to the principal's office.", Celestia said in a very annoyed and impatient tone
  488. >You wouldn't dare see how mad principal Celestia could get if you delay in going
  489. >So you rush right over
  490. >After closing the door behind you, you see the two Celestias in a stare down
  491. >The Celestia pretending to be a student seemingly unaffected by the lecturing and dressing down she no doubt already got from her other counterpart
  492. >You sit down feeling genuine fear of being involved in this confrontation and sink into the chair as if hoping you could hide
  493. >"Could you please make sense of what's going on here, and talk some sense into her? She clearly seems to know you.", she starts with a heavy sigh and pinching her nasal ridge
  494. >"She just won't drop the act that she's a student, and even keeps saying she's your girlfriend despite having never been around before.", Celestia adds before blushing a little
  495. >"Not that I would know if you have a girlfriend, but I think I'd have seen her at least once around here if she really had such a close relationship with you.", adding again, but she still wasn't done
  496. >"Why does she have to look so much like me anyway?!", she blurts out and finally seems to be done
  497. >You think you have an idea, but aren't sure how to explain
  498. >One way you could start with is certain 'incidents' before that are seldom talked about
  499. "Well, you know the 'incidents' we don't normally talk about where what can only be described as 'magic' is used?", you say as she raises an eyebrow while staying frustrated
  500. >"Yes, but what does that have to do with anything?!", she asks impatiently
  501. "You see... I'm not completely sure, but I think I can confidently say she's a counterpart of you from the other world where the magic comes from. People from that world where everyone there is normally ponies have been coming through lately...", you try explaining
  502. >Principal Celestia seems truly exasperated before saying, "You didn't think to tell me about this sooner?"
  503. "How would I?! I'd just sound like a lunatic if I said 'pony people from another dimension are coming in from a magic portal'! Would you even believe me if I said something like that without another version of you sitting right in front of you?!"
  504. >She thought about it some more before saying, "Okay, probably not..."
  505. >Then principal Celestia turns her attention back to her pony counterpart who seemed to be just amused by the conversation up to this point
  506. >"So can you drop the act now? Are you really a 'pony counterpart', and what are you really doing here?"
  507.  
  508. >"Fine, I am.", the pony Celestia starts before continuing, "I'm Princess Celestia, and the ruler of the kingdom Equestria where I'm from. I thought I could just wing it with a fake identity here to effectively take a vacation and get away from the royal duties and responsibilities for a bit."
  509. >"I'll admit not doing due diligence to discover my counterpart's position in this world was a mistake... I doubted I'd even have one.", she concedes while looking away, unable to look her counterpart in the eyes while saying that
  510. >"Though why say a student is your boyfriend? Do you have any idea how much trouble that would cause if I hadn't intervened quickly?", your principal asked her with an annoyed tone
  511. >The royal counterpart paused for a bit looking up in deep thought about how she'd explain it before answering
  512. >"Well, I wanted to have some fun with him since my number one pupil and her friends were, and they said multiple women with the same guy is normal here.", saying as your principal looked at her unsure if she's serious
  513. >"I'll have you know it's not normal here, and school staff are not allowed to have relations like that with students. So either differentiate yourself more from me, or don't be so 'familiar' with my students.", your principal chided her
  514. >Then she turns to you like it's your turn to get scolded
  515. >"Have you really been 'seeing' multiple women?", she asked with her arms folded tapping the desk with agitation
  516. "I mean... Yes, but it's hardly my fault! The women coming through the portal were pretty aggressive and forceful about it! Their Applejack for example lassoed me and tied me up before having her way with me! Not much room to say 'no' there!", you protest
  517. >"And do you know why they were so aggressive and just assumed you'd be down for it?", Celestia asked you like she was hinting at something and felt you should know the answer to it
  518. "Because I'm a guy? I mean... It's pretty safe to assume a guy is horny most of the time...", you say even having a gut feeling that's not what she meant
  519. >"Wrong!", she tells you before saying, "Anyone with eyes can see you go around being all sweet and flirty everywhere, and those six you're always around are practically your girlfriends even if you play dumb and don't take the hints that they want you.", she tells you sternly
  520. >You aren't so flirty all the time, right?
  521. >How were you 'flirting' before the pony versions escalated things rapidly?
  522. >You don't remember actually hitting on anyone before
  523. >"Not just them either, even with me!", she says with both anger and bashfulness before adding, "Always acting helpful before letting your eyes rest on my chest, looking up at me when I'm close with your lips looking like you're begging me to just lean in and kiss you, and just tempting me to just take you for myself..."
  524. >She then blushes deeply realizing what she just admitted to before saying, "That's it! You're getting detention for a week!"
  525. "For what?!", you ask with disbelief
  526.  
  527. "For being a man whore! That's why!", your principal tells you
  528. "It may be immoral, but it's not specifically against school rules!", you say like you hope you can lawyer your way out of it
  529. >"I have discretion to give detention for things that aren't specifically mentioned in school rules! Just take it on the chin and be glad I'm not calling your parents about it!", She tells you and you sink in your chair in defeat
  530. >"Wow, you sound like you really need to get laid.", the royal Celestia comments in a somewhat teasing fashion
  531. >"Like I'd take that from you, and you're not helping!", she says before the wheels start turning in her head
  532. >"Okay, how about we make a deal here?", your principal says before laying out the idea
  533. >"I'll register you as a foreign exchange student, and you dress more appropriately while doing stuff like styling your hair different to look more like a different person.", she says as the royal counterpart looked eager to accept, but she wasn't done yet
  534. >"But!-", she said with a dramatic pause before adding what comes after that, "You will have to occasionally swap with me, and let me pretend to be the foreign exchange student."
  535. >"Why would I do that?", the royal Celestia asked indignantly
  536. >"You said you wanted a break? Well I need one too! Don't think I'll go through all this and pull strings without getting anything myself from it! Take the deal or you get nothing!", the principal said firmly putting her foot down
  537. >"Fine, we'll do it your way.", the royal Celestia concedes
  538. "Why would you do that though? Couldn't you just actually go on vacation?", you ask and they both look at you funny
  539. >"Honestly, are all boys in your world so dense? Can you really not understand why an older woman would want to feel young again, and forgo their responsibilities? Just for a bit?", the royal Celestia chides you teasingly
  540. >"You'll see why in due time, just make sure your young man whore body is kept ready for your 'foreign exchange student sweetheart'~.", the principal say teasingly and flirtatiously
  541. >The royal Celestia chuckles and chimes in dog piling on you, "That's right, and I'll be seeing you soon, boy toy~."
  542. >"Not especially soon.", the principal corrects her before adding, "You need to learn how to be a principal first if you're going to be able to swap places with me."
  543. >Grabbing her counterpart by the ear and making it clear she's not going anywhere until the human world's rules and social norms for a principal have been drilled into her soul
  544. >Your principal then turns to you saying, "You're free to go now, but you've still got detention for a week. Don't think I've forgotten that."
  545. >She then does the double finger 'I'm watching you' hand gesture as you get out of the chair and leave
  546. >Closing the door behind you, you hope the rest of the day won't be so nerve wracking
  547.  
  548. >You go to your first class today, which was a home ec class
  549. >Pinkie had convinced you to take the class with her because cooking is a valuable skill, and Fluttershy is there too
  550. >Though knowing now how Pinkie really feels about you, you can't help wondering if there was another reason for it
  551. >Actually, Pinkie would often act 'wifely' with you in the class
  552. >Dear god, you feel like an idiot
  553. >Sure, you just chalked it up to Pinkie being playful, but now it feels like you were ignoring a bright neon sign right against your eyeballs that said "Pinkie wants to be your wife!"
  554. >Actually, why was Fluttershy there?
  555. >She's never seemed super interested in cooking...
  556. >You can't stand around thinking about it too much and head into the class
  557. >Pinkie waves to you energetically and invited you over while Fluttershy shyly fidgets at the table you normally have the class with them at
  558. >From the start it seems like this wouldn't be a normal iteration of the class
  559. >Pinkie seemed even more knowledgeable about cooking as she expertly went step by step with what we were told to try to cook before the teacher even told us the next steps
  560. "Pssst, are you the pony Pinkie?", you whisper in her ear
  561. >"Yeppers~!", Pinkie said without bothering to whisper
  562. >Though she lowered her voice more after thinking about what she'd say next before saying, "She took the day off to talk with her family more seriously, and asked me to cover for her."
  563. >You don't think that bodes well for you
  564. >"Sorry I'm stealing the thunder from 'Momma Flutters' being so good at cooking today~."
  565. >She said teasingly half to you, and half to Fluttershy who reacted with an angry blush
  566. >"Are you the pony Pinkie?", Fluttershy asked quietly with anger rising in her voice
  567. >"Yeppers~!", she repeated they same way she did when you asked
  568. >"It seems I'm going to need to have a serious talk with my pony counterpart...", she said as you worried for them
  569. >It must be embarrassing giving other pony counterparts the wrong idea about her
  570. >"I told her about that kink in confidence!", she hissed under her breath into Pinkie's ear
  571. >Uhmmm, what?
  572. >"Don't be so embarrassed about it Fluttershy, we all have our thing~.", Pinkie told her reassuringly
  573. >Fluttershy then covers her ears symbolically before saying, "My sweet, innocent, little Anon... Don't listen to such perversions."
  574. >"Would you feel better if he wasn't turned off by knowing this about you?", Pinkie asked her
  575. >"Not in class...", FLuttershy whispered with a blush before adding, "I-I guess I wouldn't be as mad if he'd indulge me with it..."
  576. >A fierce blush comes across your face remembering what the pony Fluttershy said at the end of fucking you
  577. "H-how would I 'indulge' you with it?", you asked quietly seriously unsure what they're talking about, but not saying you wouldn't do it
  578.  
  579. >Pinkie giggles before whispering in your ear, "Isn't it obvious from how I called her, 'mommy Flutters', act like she's your mom~. She's here to 'take care of' her sweet little boy, and make sure you know how much she loves you~."
  580. >You know it can't literally be acting like she's your mom if it's a 'kink' and 'perverse'
  581. >Fluttershy looks like she's about to hyperventilate as she whispers, "W-we can't do that here... It's too much..."
  582. >Though Pinkie pushes you closer to her, saying, "Go on, Nonners~."
  583. "I think Fluttershy is right, it seems like something that should be done more in private.", you say before pointing out that other people in the class were starting to glace over to you three suspiciously
  584. >Not much, but enough to give you pause about giving them anymore reason to watch what you're doing
  585. >"You've got a lot on your plate, Nonners~. Maybe you should try to keep a schedule for this stuff~.", Pinkie says tauntingly
  586. >You might seriously consider that, if you were the one even making decisions about it
  587. "You're talking like I'm in charge.", you say as Pinkie giggles
  588. >Fluttershy seems confused about what Pinkie is referring to, but asks you "Could you please come over to my place tonight?"
  589. "I'll have to ask my parents, but I'll do it if I can. Also I'd have to go after detention...", you say as Fluttershy seems concerned
  590. >"Detention?! Did Celestia give you detention when she called you to her office?!", she asks having clearly heard the intercom announcement calling you to her office
  591. "Yeah... For a week. I don't really want to openly talk about why, but it's not as serious as it sounds...", you try to reassure her
  592. >"Come on, Nonners, don't leave ME hanging! Tell me, tell me~! What'd you do~?!", Pinkie taunts and teases you
  593. >You whisper as quietly as you can in pony Pinkie's ear about Celestia being mad about pony Celestia showing up and taking it out on you, while saying it's for you being a 'man whore'
  594. >Pinkie struggles to not laugh out loud before whispering back in your ear, "You are though~."
  595. >You couldn't argue with that
  596. >Fluttershy seemed consistently worried about you while also looking forward to the idea of having you over to her place tonight
  597. >The rest of the class goes relatively smoothly, and after class you head to the next one
  598. >You're surprised to go between classes without being jumped, but somehow it happens
  599. >You don't share the next class, social studies, with anyone you knew, besides it being taught by Cheerilee, but it looked like that changed this time
  600. >Cheerilee looks embarrassed and indignant as she introduces 'a new student' to the class
  601. >It's pony Celestia in her top with no bra and short skirt
  602. >Looks like 'dressing more appropriately didn't happen today, but at least her hair in done differently into a ponytail and curls rather than loose and straight
  603. >She also has glasses on now and fake braces
  604.  
  605. >"This is Sunny, and she's a foreign exchange student...", she says like she's barely able to not just call out who she's convinced is Celestia pulling some shit
  606. >Though the class starts commenting on how they'd seen her and Celestia in the same place, or at least hearing about it
  607. >"Hey there, sorry if I looked too much like my aunt Celestia. I just got here from our home country and didn't realize how much our family resemblance would be since it's been a while since I last saw her.", she explains as the class seems to accept that
  608. >Cheerilee still seems suspicious of it, but after hearing the students seems to decide to let her doubts rest for now
  609. >Throughout the class 'Sunny' sits next to you and flirts with you in typical teenage ways
  610. >She even tries passing a note to you that Cheerilee intercepts
  611. >Cheerilee reads it and blushes before saying, "No passing notes in class!"
  612. >Returning to her desk with a huff she scowls at Sunny and seems to more believe she's a legitimate teenager and not Celestia pretending
  613. >While Cheerilee is distracted and grumbling 'Sunny' whispers in your ear, "Meet me behind the school during break."
  614. >She then grabs and squeezes your crotch before snapping back to a normal position when Cheerilee looks forward again
  615. >After class ends it's time for that break
  616. >You think you'll split up and meet where she wanted, but she clearly gets the idea you can just go there together
  617. >Via her picking you up by your stomach and carrying you there
  618. >Cheerilee is very flustered watching her carry you off with her having no doubt seen the note the probably said to meet her there
  619. >She takes you out to the back of the school where delinquents often hang out
  620. >Pinning you against the wall and yanking your pants down before mounting you
  621. >You struggle to hold her up because of her size as her cougar pussy enveloped your cock
  622. >Fighting through it knowing she'd think you're implying she's fat if you complain about it
  623. >Despite it more being about her height and overall size rather than her being fat
  624. >After you thrust up into her and she bounces up her body slams back down on you with staggering force
  625. >"Hey, this is my territory, dorks!", someone yells with a somewhat familiar voice
  626. >Looking over with your strength waning you see it's Gilda
  627. >"Can't you see my boy toy's dick in me?! I'm busy, bitch, fuck off!", Sunny snaps at her as Gilda looks shocked finally realizing what she walked in on
  628. >You lean back more against the wall putting as much of your combined weight with her as possible to save your strength during this interruption
  629. >She stares at your dick in her for a second, before coming to her senses but with a deep blush
  630. >"This isn't over, bitch! You'll regret this!", Gilda says before stomping off in a huff
  631. >"You can continue now, Anon. You're not to say I'm overweight, are you?", she says as you nervously shake your head
  632.  
  633. "O-of course not, Sunny! Your curvy body is perfect the way it is! I'm just a little out of shape, that's all!", You say before starting to thrust up in her again
  634. >She scowls a little feeling like you're still saying she's overweight, maybe she's more sensitive about it than you thought
  635. >"Also, without that brat Gilda here anymore I don't think we have to worry about anyone else showing up, you can just call me Celestia.", she says apparently not wanting to be called 'Sunny' if she doesn't have to
  636. >"Be a little more passionate about it too! Act more like we're teen lovers having indiscriminate sex like monkey brained animals!", she commands you
  637. >You feel like you're going to cum when you thrust up into her and bounce her curvy cougar body on you as hard as you can
  638. "I-I'm gonna cum, my goddess!", you tell her as she scowls at you again
  639. >"I'm not the pony bitch! Quit being so dense, Anon!", she says as the realization you're having sex with your principle pushes you over the edge, and makes you cum in her
  640. >During your orgasm you slide down the wall to the ground as Celestia stays to the hilt on you
  641. "It's you... Then what's up with the fake braces and glasses?", you ask her
  642. >"The glasses may be costime glasses, but the braces are my real braces from when I was a teenager...", she tells you with some embarrassment
  643. >You can't help trying to imagine a teenage Celestia with braces on
  644. >It's kind of cute actually
  645. >"Now shut up and kiss me!", she says before locking lips with you
  646. >Her braces make it somewhat awkward to kiss her, and you're worried about her braces cutting the inside of your mouth
  647. >Though you suppose that's part of the 'teenage experience' she wants to recreate
  648. >After a bit of that and Celestia getting done enjoying the afterglow with your cum leaking from your principal's pussy around the base of your shaft she stops and gets off of you
  649. >"Now, if anyone asks confronts you about it you did this with 'Sunny', okay. 'Celestia' the principal is still in her office, understand."
  650. "Crystal clear!", you say while unsure exactly how to react with her acting authoritative while also not waning you to treat her like she's principal
  651. >"So, what are you going to call me when I'm like this?", she asks you like it's a quiz
  652. "Mistress Sunny?", you respond unsure about it
  653. >"That's fine, I guess, but say it more clearly like you mean it.", but without much time she helps you both get cleaned up instead of pushing you on it more
  654. >"Now get to class, and don't be late.", she commands you, and you head off not daring to disobey
  655. >At least you would if the intercom didn't buzz to life with an announcement related to you
  656. >"Anonymous and Gilda, please report to the guidance councilor's office.", is heard over the intercom as you're really confused about that one
  657. >Hoping it'll be short you go over there
  658. >In the office Chrysalis is sitting at her desk with Gilda sitting with her arms folded in a huff
  659.  
  660. >"Now that Anon's here, let's discuss your relationship here.", Chrysalis starts
  661. >"What the hell are you talking about?!", Gilda protests
  662. >"Now, now, Gilda, let me finish.", Chrysalis says before continuing
  663. >"Cheerilee tells me Anon here is falling in with a bad crowd and being pushed around by a flirty delinquent. Who else could it be but you, Gilda?"
  664. >Gilda huffs before answering, "It's that new transfer student that looks like a dorky teenage Celestia! That's who should be here instead of me! I'm innocent here!"
  665. >"Now, now, Gilda, let's not pretend you haven't been jealous of Anon's more straight laced friends, and wished he'd hang out with you instead. I'm no one to just belive rumors like that anyway.", she said as Gilda fumed
  666. >"A new student that looks like Celestia? That's just silly. Sure I like rumors, but couldn't it have been more believable?", Chrysalis commented sounding amused
  667. >"It's great you've convinced him to give you a chance, but don't cause trouble with your teenage romance drama crap, okay?", Chrysalis adds as Gilda explodes
  668. >"Fuck you! I'm serious about it being that other bitch! Also did you really have to say that shit with Anon here?! These sessions aren't supposed to be snitched on!", she screamed angrily
  669. "Not to specifically defend Gilda, but it's true. It was a new girl, Sunny who disrupted Cheerilee's class flirting with me.", you say as Gilda sticks out her tongue at you like a bratty kid
  670. >Chrysalis sighs, "Not you too, Anon... I thought you were more mature than that.", she says before adding, "Dating a delinquent isn't that bad you need deny it so hard. Just kiss and make up with her, and maybe help her fly right while you're at it."
  671. "I'm serious, I'm not dating her! How is it like I'm so popular?!", You say as they both look at you like they think you're joking
  672. >"You ARE popular, Anonymous. A cute boy who's eager to please and does whatever girls want? What's not to like about that~.", she says in an almost flirty way
  673. >"He doesn't do whatever I want!", Gilda pouts while glancing over at you putting extra emphasis on 'I'
  674. >"Well, then maybe that should change a little~?", Chrysalis says while looking at you
  675. "Even if I'm not dating her?", you ask as it feels like you're getting 'too many girlfriends'
  676. >"Well, I say you are dating me!", Gilda retorts, now leaning into it
  677. >"See how good it feels when you're honest?", Chrysalis says as you're further pressured
  678. "Would you really want to date the boy equivalent of a town bicycle?", you say thinking she expects to have you all to herself now
  679. >"Did I stutter, dork? I know you are, and I'm saying I want my turn!", she says as you're floored
  680. >"Maybe don't call your boyfriend a dork?", Chrysalis tells her
  681. >"It's a term of endearment when I call him that, okay?!", Gilda doubles down on it
  682. >Chrysalis sighs and just accepts she won't convince Gilda otherwise

Anon the unlucky

by StreamofGreen

Pie Family Harem

by StreamofGreen

Sudden Maud+Momma Ponk

by StreamofGreen

Twist Mom

by StreamofGreen

Mad Scientist Twilight Mom

by StreamofGreen